Russian Formalists’ approach to Film Art

Judit Bárdos, ELTE Művészetelméleti és Médiakutatási Intézet, Esztétika Tanszék

E-mail: bardos.judit224@gmail.com

doi: 10.14672/VDS20243IP15

(http://www.doi.org/10.14672/VDS20243IP15)

(https://levocidisophia.it/2024/12/30/russian-formalists-approach-to-film-art1/)

Russian Formalists’ approach to Film Art[1] © 2024 by Bárdos Judit is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

Abstractus

In the 1920s, directors, actors, writers, and other collaborators enthusiastically participated in the birth of cinema as “the primary art.” Although the foundations of the film industry were almost nonexistent in 1922 and 1923, by 1924-1925, great masterpieces were created, followed by a flourishing wave of sophisticated art films. During this period, a complex film culture has been developed, characterized by artistic movements, aesthetic discussions, experiments, and formulation of theories. The era was marked by revolutionary fervor, the creation of a genuine artistic community, and a fertile atmosphere, with popular cinema gaining great potential for social influence. These factors encouraged many writers, poets, artists, and composers to work on screenplays, essays, and film reviews. The Russian Formalist school played a significant role, with scholars like Yuri Tynianov, Viktor Shklovsky, and Adrian Piotrovsky, contributing to the development of art cinema, actively participating in film production, and teaching at film schools. This interdisciplinary approach between literary theory and film practice was essential for the creation of a new form of artistic expression.

Keywords: Cinema, Avant-garde, Russian Formalism, Interdisciplinary Collaboration, Social Art

Introduction

The group published a great variety of essays on film art, contributed to discussions about film art, and published a textbook on film theory, entitled Poetics of Cinema[4] (1927). Shklovsky and Piotrovsky published several books on film which was not an uncommon activity at that time, as the newborn art form already had an immense specialised literature. Various periodicals were issued, original theoretical works as well as translations of foreign textbooks. The degree to which these scholars of literature remain largely unknown, may also be because they did not constitute an organic school or trend; they did not emphasise their own ingenuity, individuality, or theoretical significance in an age of avant-garde declarations, various artistic programs, experiments, and pronounced individualism. Without a definitive ‘ars poetica’ their works were footnotes or critical remarks on the new art form in addition to their everyday work and they probably did not especially care to count these essays within their oeuvres or within the theory of film as an organic body. Today, seeing their work from a historical perspective, we can discover the common theoretical and conceptual ground of their articles and essays, and we can also reveal their great achievements as scholars of silent film and the general aesthetics of film art. Their concept of art and their critical ideas are considered today to be genuine and inspiring.

Foundations of their approach to art

Russian formalists refuted any distinction between content and form. Instead of the concept of ‘content’ they referred to ‘material’ or texture, e.g., the sum of facts, objects, motivations, and ideas serving as a ground for artworks. Instead of the term ‘form’ they referred to приём ‘pryom’ meaning the instruments, methods, approaches, and processes involved in producing a work of art. An artist or author creates his work of art out of some material, texture, via specific means such as repetition, suspension, contrast, or conflict, and this material by itself outside the realm of art becomes a texture, a basic constituent of artistic creation. Construction is then composed by interrelationships of specific means. Although a sort of duality between texture and artistic means remains, this new pair of categories has nevertheless contributed to a rather sophisticated approach to the composition of artworks, for it rejects the earlier static view whereby form was exterior to material and texture. Hence, any work of art was to be considered a dynamic structure composed of various levels. Tynianov’s contribution to Shklovsky’s basic principles was the concept of historic character: which everyday social events turn out to be an artistic expression, which ones are transferred from marginality into the very centre of art – all this constitutes a function of historical processes. When a fact enters the structure of artworks, because of its dynamic character it will in turn become distorted and be credited with a new meaning and form; it will also acquire a new function and will become an organic part of a composition and it will enter a system of interrelationships with various other factors. There is no unchanging, fixed, direct texture or rough fact in a work of art, there is only an artistic fact with specific meanings and functions formed and organised in an artistic manner through various artistic instruments.

Through this concept they could overcome the traditional film theories based in immediacy and authenticity. The very essence of moving pictures had fascinated early audiences and theoreticians by its illusions of authenticity, it was as if the real world passed before their very eyes on the large screen. It was the early Russian scholars who finally stated that genuine authenticity was but an illusion. In the textbook [Kinematograph 1919]Sidorova had stated as early as in 1919 that photography as a texture was merely some sort of abstraction, a ‘conditionality’, for it lacked space, depth of focus, colour and sound, however, these very shortcomings might serve as grounds for artistic creation. Employing artistic means, two-dimensional pictures might suggest space relationships and contribute to the creation of the ‘conditionality’ necessary to any sort of artistic experience.

A starting point for the formalist scholars of literature had been the fact that any work of art constitutes a complex, multilevel structure, something more than mere authenticity, more than just referring to a realistic expression of reality addressed to various senses. Instead, it is a creation of an artistic conditionality based on one sense – vision. Film art makes complex relationships perceptible, communication within the realm of visualisation elevate its expressiveness and refer to a realm not directly visible – the realm of the emotional, conceptual, and atmospheric. Although this concept had not been expressed by these scholars as a doctrine, it became manifest through their approaches to literature and the arts. For this reason, an approach inherent in another form of art – literature – had been fruitful; early film scholars and creative filmmakers conceived motion pictures as something new and uniquely cinematographic manifested by the authenticity of photography. They pioneered the development of film theory by introducing the concept of artistic “условность”, i.e., conditionality, which formed the base for the appreciation and study of film, and a proper approach to solving theoretical problems.

Approaches to film art

For Russian formalists, the Standards of film evaluation came from the need for conditionality. They did not attempt to emulate the method of literary scholarship; on the contrary, they emphasised differences between literature and film. Shklovsky referred to film as a form of expression presenting visible, solid forms of reality that consequently cannot develop the sophisticated network characterising the verbal texture of literature. Hence, its communication system of concepts and images is rather indirect when compared to the directly perceived visual texture of photography. A multi-faceted relation to objects characterising literary style cannot be realised in film art. However, filmmakers still can reach some fullness of communication, interrelation of various elements, they can suggest a sophisticated creative relationship. This fullness has also been a criterion for artistic values; the more multi-layered, the more organic a film’s composition is, the higher is its aesthetic value. There is no ‘rough fact’ to be observed, as Dziga Vertov declared in his artistic manifesto, because anything can become fact in motion picture. If fragments of reality are too close to rough facts, they cannot become organic components of a work of art; they are not inspired with an interrelation and the film’s value will be decreased. Russian formalists considered film to be a dynamic composition; they focused on this composition as an organic unity instead of the primary authenticity of all parts, and they also recognised that the actual impact and authenticity of all parts are a function of composition as an organic unity.

Turning back to the twenties: the relationship between scholars and film art was more than writing film reviews. Their contribution to filmmakers of ‘FEKS’ was the rare case of a mutual relationship between artistic practices and theories – unlike ‘Minerva’s Owl’ beginning its flight after sundown. This theory did not necessarily study features of declining artistic forms generalising these features afterwards. On the contrary, it preceded and enriched artistic practices.

Tynianov was the scriptwriter of Kozintsev’s and Trauberg’s The Cloak and The Club of the Big Deed. Hence, he had the opportunity to turn his theory into practice: first, that feature film is not merely a narration of some story but rather a manyfold organic composition whereby the meaning of the individual components and images is a function of their contribution to the whole; second, he confirmed his concept of the ‘filmic translation’ of literature when the artistic aim is not a reconstruction of parts (in the case of historical films, or of the historic events themselves), but rather a recollection of the Zeitgeist of the age presented through the artistic means of cinematography, in other words, to create a genuine world of cinematography. Tynianov recalled in his essay Libretto of the Cloak [Tynianov 1926] how this film’s composition was developed by deliberately arranging various motifs by Gogol. Tynianov himself, not only as an historian and theorist of literature but also as an innovator in the historical novel genre, and author of short stories, exerted great impact on Kozintsev and Trauberg through his concept of history. His approach had determined the atmosphere and style of The Cloak and The Club of the Big Deed. A term of literary scholarship; the principle of ‘остронение’ (removal, making particular) had its direct impact on moving pictures made by the group “FEKS”. They considered one of the basic inspirations in the development of art the fact that through canonization or consolidation of any motive, its artistic impact diminishes, and its reception gradually becomes automatized. That motive in question will become meaningful, expressive, significant when a created particularity has elevated it over an automated sensitivity, common background, and system of relationships. Artistic movements of the twenties were characterised by most strident, extreme, provocative forms of expression by such masters as Vsevolod Meyerhold, Kozintsev, and Eisenstein in their stage directing, that also characterised methods of montage in contemporary Russian films and fine arts; for these artists and authors had aimed for a forceful, sweeping impact on their audiences, in their view art had a direct role in transforming reality and consciousness. This concept had been manifestly declared in Eisenstein’s essay Montage of Attractions [Eisenstein 1964] and in Lev Vygotsky’s conception of the psychology of art. The idea of extravagant forms and contrasts as a source of artistic expression and impact had just been ‘in the air’ at that time. Nevertheless, the specific concepts of formalists had their peculiar, unique character even without the general framework, for they considered not conflicts and contrasts themselves as a basic element of expression and impact, but rather the removal of objects from their ordinary environment and the subsequent placement into an unusual context. Films made by the eccentric group ‘FEKS’ were inspired by this concept. We can, for instance, recall this process of ‘making something particular’ in Devil’s Wheel, where a love story takes place not in its typical milieu, but on a roller coaster; or in The Club of the Big Deed where various events of a revolt in the 19th century take place not within some historical setting or neutral environment, but in a pub. People and objects have new relationships, emotions are expressed through unusual gestures, and so on.

Conditionality was a central term of essays and articles written by Russian formalists. This concept renewed all basic theoretical problems, such as analysing movement, space–time relations, the specific characters of film art. The photography of movement was, at the time, a great technical innovation. Early theorists of film art enthusiastically celebrated the ability of motion pictures to render and communicate movement – crowd scenes as well as a quiver of leaves. Shklovsky, on the other hand, emphasized in his book Literature and Film (1923) that film had a future as an art form only if it surpasses the naturalistic photography of movement by structuring an artistic symbol system and by treating movement as a ‘conditional system of signs’.

Russian formalists did not seek a unique condition for particularity of film art that would distinguish it from other artistic forms of expression. A good example of this approach is Piotrovskij’s The Impact of the Film on the Arts [Poetics of Cinema 1927]. When comparing film to other arts, he started from the assumption that film is no more an ‘immediate reality’ than a theatrical performance or a painting; it has similarly created its conditionality, its ‘homogenous texture’, its ‘own unique universe’ (to use today’s term). Starting from this basic feature of expression, the shared aspects rather than superficial differences in forms and instruments are revealed; and through this analysis significant differences were revealed as well. The very criteria that make silent film an independent art, are its basic aesthetic features. Tynianov, in his essay Motion Pictures, Words, Music [Tynianov 1926], analysed features of making space and time dimensions through film art. Unlike actual space, in which players are present as flesh and blood human beings, and in which a developing narrative line exists, film is an ‘abstract form of expression’: it is not related to any actual space; there is neither scenery, depth of the stage, an actual human body, nor a human voice present. Most extreme jumps in space, time, as well as a multi-scene, parallel story lines are possible. Since that time, of course, modern theatre has also developed a similarly deliberate structuring of space and time; however, these solutions are not inherently given in the dramatic arts: they constitute rather recent developments and to a certain extent reflect the impact of film art and of modern epical treatment.

Boris Eichenbaum’s approach to differences between film and literature, started from a condition of reception outlined in his essay Literature and Film [Poetics of Cinema 1927]. The process of reception of a film operates in reverse to that of reading: the viewer starts from the manifest, visible object and reaches interpretation, analysis, interlocking various elements, constructing an ‘interior conversation’, thus building in his/her mind a private ‘inner film’. Silent film does not lack sound, speech, the verbal element, language; it merely lacks the ‘audible world’, as Eichenbaum recognised. Film appeals not directly to intellect, but rather to the ‘transmental spheres’ through a dreamlike sense, a quasi-real atmosphere of sounds, voices, and musical emotions. This concept is a forerunner to our contemporary idea of the atmospheric unity as the centre of film. Introducing the term ‘transmental’, Eichenbaum had not entirely left film to the subjective realm; what is more, he stated that motion picture became a social phenomenon and form of expression when related that transmental sphere to specific contents. Content, the meaning of films, has not been concentrated in words, nor it is identical with events seen on the screen; it is rather a particular content, a photogenic texture expressed through mimesis, gestures, reductions in perspective, similar to the content of music and poetry. Hence, when comparing film to literature, we can recognise the very specific feature of film art. Eichenbaum, unlike early theorists, discovered this specific character not in one isolated factor, but rather in photogeneity, as well as in montage, in the social content of film, and in the process whereby film art is addressed in a well-defined way to a well-defined psychological sphere of personality.

In his essay [Poetics of Film1927] Eichenbaum followed his analysis of perception of film. ‘Conditions of filmic discourse encourage the viewer to feel himself completely isolated – conditions of a viewer are close to an individual, intimate contemplation.’ A film viewer sitting in a theatre does not consider or feel himself as a member of a group or a participant in a collective reception, sharing some common experience, but he/she shares an individual identification with the players. (This feature is also inherent in artistic means of film, in the potentiality of ‘subjective’ and moving camera, in that the viewer can ‘see’ through the eyes of any filmic character or can ‘move’ with the camera.) Simply viewing a motion picture, however, does not constitute a collective experience; traditionally developed theatrical filmviewing is merely a function of practical and financial considerations. Eichenbaum, as a pioneer of film theory, recognised early on that film is not necessarily a popular art; its mass character is only superficial, external, a quantitative factor; a function of capital and profit – seeking business formation. It is not inherent in the essential features of reception and creation in filmmaking. The concept of a homogenous audience is but an illusion, as well as the notion of forming a temporary community, even though this illusion had contributed to the early success and popularity of motion pictures. Early film theorists (such as Béla Balázs) saw some interconnection between ‘democratic art’ breaking linguistic barriers to reaching the audiences-at-large, who did not require any specific educational background to experience motion pictures, and the idea of a new folk art joining social classes or even unifying nations. By the end of the twenties, the Russian revolution had been consolidated, and film art and film theory had also left their ‘infancy’ behind, entering their ‘adolescence’, giving birth to a more radical consideration of the social impact of film art.

The most elaborate discussion of theoretical considerations of specific cinematographic features by Russian formalists can be found in their textbook Poetics of Cinema. In their essays, Eichenbaum and Tynianov offered sophisticated aesthetic elaborations on these features.

Russian film theory in the twenties is generally considered to be the age of absolutism of montage theory. However, it was neither general, nor unified. It was characteristic of the Russian formalists, as well as Eisenstein, who had just started extending and elaborating this theory in a very sophisticated manner. In which respect, then, is the film-specific analysis of Poetics of Cinema modern?

The Russian formalists’ emphasis on function within composition has re-evaluated photogeneity and montage themselves. Eichenbaum and Tynjanov recognised that there is no ‘photogenic object’ in and of itself; it assumes such a quality through angles, composition, light, that is photogeneity is a function of a film’s construction and style. Any object can be photogenic if we show it in another perspective, taken out of the context of immediate reception, and approached as a strange object. Film becomes a form of expression, Eichenbaum wrote, when a sense of distance from the object presented is developed; when filmmakers begin to ‘deform’ the usual vision through composition shots, various combinations of light, angles, common narrative standards, characters, situations are ‘deformed’ via montage.  Eichenbaum discovered that the basic feature of development of film art is constituted by filmmakers’ process of shedding their initial ‘primitive naturalism’ – the notion of creating the illusion of reality – in favour of realising the courage to ‘deform’, to develop their individual stylistic clues (such as panning, specific angles, etc.).

Eichenbaum wrote that the function of montage (montage can vary from the simple joining of events to the suggestion of conceptual relations or the development of a film’s own time, space, and rhythm) is determined even within the framework of individual images, just as the meaning of individual components is determined by composition as an organic unity. Shots, angles, and montage can accelerate or decelerate rhythm. This rhythm deviates from narrative development; the crossing or even conflicting of these two speeds creates a specific cinematographic time. The higher the difference between speed of montage and that of narrative development, the higher the emotional tension of the audience.

Tynjanov emphasised [Poetics of Cinema 1927] that the more motion pictures give up the naturalistic reproduction of reality, the more they will firmly utilise sensual “reduction and conditionality, the more they will constitute a genuine form of expression”. Films used to be black and white, two-dimensional, and silent. They lacked depth, colour, and sound. Technical development had already flashed some perspective of three-dimensional picture, colour, and sound; the possibility of addressing motion pictures to other, additional senses is possible, thus enabling a reproduction of the real world increasingly similar to the actual perception of reality itself. Tynjanov clearly recognised that on the one hand a precise naturalistic reproduction is not possible, on the other hand, it would also be redundant. It is not possible, for each form of expression focuses on some selected sense and cannot match the abundance of real-life perception variety and abundance of detail. It would also be redundant, because reaching an abundance is not the goal of artistic expression. On the contrary, a work of art has its impact within the realm of one organ of sense, using its means in a developed, intensified way.

‘[The] poor and flat, colourless quality of film turned out to be a positive real artistic instrument’, Tynjanov wrote[5].

Indeed, if we do not possess colour, alternation of exposure of various grade and direction could serve as an expressive instrument of style. The ‘flat’ character of the two-dimensional image served the possibility of simultaneous sequences, panning, and the specific Russian school of montage: namely, the possibility of connecting two shots to create a powerful effect through conceptual or emotional association. The ‘poorness’ of film is in fact a constructive principle of film exactly in the same way as other forms of expression are based on sensual homogeneity. This was the modern film-specific analysis of the Russian Formalists. 


[1]This text is a revised version of an essay published earlier with the title Russian Formalists and Film Art. (In Film: Signs Discourse. European Journal for Semiotic Studies. 1990 /1-2. Wien – Barcelona – Budapest – Perpignan). Also revised by Ágnes Katalin Kelemen, research assistant at the CEU Democracy Institute, and by Jozsef Nagy, academic researcher from Budapest University of Technology and Economics.

[2]The Russian Formalist School (Boris Eichenbaum, Jury Tynianov, Viktor Shklovsky, (Roman Jacobson, Osip Brik, Boris Tomashevsky) was founded 1916 at St. Petersburg and led by Viktor Shklovsky. (It existed till 1930).

[3]FEKS, Фабрика Эксцентрического Aктёра: a group of film artists and theatre men in the twenties in Leningrad. Its members: Grigori Kozintsev, Leonid Trauberg, Sergei Yutkevich, Sergei Gerasimov.

[4]Поэтика кино, 1927, Academia, Leningrad. Poetics of Cinema 1982, in: Russian Poetics in Translation No 9. The contributors of the volume were Boris Eichenbaum, Viktor Shklovszky, Adrian Piotrovsky, Boris Kazansky, Yuri Tynianov.

[5]Поэтика кино, 1927, Academia, Leningrad. Poetics of Cinema 1982, in: Russian Poetics in Translation No 9. The contributors of the volume were Boris Eichenbaum, Viktor Shklovszky, Adrian Piotrovsky, Boris Kazansky, Yuri Tynianov. Citazione nel contributoi di Tynianov.